I was disappointed to read Commissioner Kerrick Johnson’s commentary defending the governor’s veto of H.727, legislation I introduced to strengthen protections for Vermonters from large data center development.
My disappointment actually extends beyond this veto. When this administration avoids or refuses to engage with the Legislature, it prevents elected representatives and the administration’s own experts from working together on behalf of Vermonters. Governing across branches and parties requires acting in good faith with a willingness to explain concerns, answer questions, and work through disagreements.
Vermont has many strong environmental protection laws. H.727 would have strengthened them with requirements specifically for data centers, addressing electricity costs, water use, pollution, public reporting, and financial responsibility if a project failed.
Initially, the administration acknowledged the need. Commissioner Johnson testified that existing protections “…they absolutely could be strengthened, and likely they should.” Another administration expert testified to the opportunity for collaboration to make those protections “…rock solid..”
That should have been the foundation for working together to protect Vermonters.
Legislators bring their communities’ experiences. Agency staff bring technical expertise and responsibility for implementing laws. Public testimony helps us test assumptions and improve legislation.
But when the Senate’s version returned to the House, the administration called me and said they weren’t even going to bother coming to testify about their opposition.
That was deeply disheartening. At a minimum, we could have heard about concerns, considered proposed changes, and explained remaining disagreements to the public.
Instead, the governor vetoed the bill. Commissioner Johnson now asks in his op-ed whether existing protections could be improved and answers, “Sure.”
The administration also claims the bill would harm businesses beyond data centers. Officials did not raise that concern during their House or Senate testimony. H.727 specifically defined the facilities it covered. If the administration believed other businesses would be affected, legislators needed a specific explanation and an opportunity to address it.
The administration’s refusal to engage with the Legislature is even more concerning when it comes to artificial intelligence.
This summer, I learned at a public technology conference that Vermont was participating in Anthropic’s public-sector AI cybersecurity initiative associated with Project Glasswing. Decisions had already been made before legislators knew Vermont was participating. The Secretary of Digital Services told me that participation was not public, although I had just heard it announced at a conference attended by hundreds of people.
I began asking basic oversight questions: Who authorized participation? What agreements were signed? What state information could be accessed or retained? What obligations had Vermont accepted? Who would be accountable if something went wrong?
Those questions concern the security of public systems and information when using AI, the use of public resources, and responsibility for government actions.
The Joint Information Technology Oversight Committee is examining the activity. But explanations after commitments are made cannot substitute for following applicable procurement requirements and involving oversight early enough to influence decisions.
AI can help public employees and improve cybersecurity. Those possibilities make careful evaluation necessary. They do not justify bypassing a co equal branch of government.
We need the administration’s experts publicly working with legislators to establish what is permitted, what is protected, and who will be responsible if things go wrong.
We can disagree about the right protections. We should revise proposals when evidence supports a better approach. But collaboration requires showing up in good faith, providing information, and answering questions.
AI and data center development are moving rapidly, with major consequences for how our personal information is collected and used. Decisions are being made before the public even knows what is proposed. Vermont must do things differently from Washington, D.C.. We need Vermont’s administration working with legislators to keep Vermonters informed, give them a meaningful voice, and build policy openly and collaboratively before commitments are made.
Discover more from Vermont State Representative Laura Sibilia
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
I absolutely agree with your concerns. I hope that those who most need to hear you are paying attention.
Pingback: Sibilia: Statement on the 2026 Election Results – Vermont State Representative Laura Sibilia